Roman Polanski: Wanted and Desired (Thinkfilm, NR)
Written by Sarah Boslaugh
Tuesday, 16 June 2009
Zenovich finds plenty of guilt to spread around to
others involved in the case.
It's not unprecedented for Oscar
winners to fail to pick up their awards in person. Sometimes they are making a
political statement (Marlon Brando) or expressing disdain for the awards
themselves (George C. Scott), and sometimes the cause is ill health (Satyajit
Ray) or death (Heath Ledger, Howard Ashman). But Roman Polanski was not present
to collect the 2002 Best Directing Oscar for The Pianist for a different reason: He would have been arrested
upon entry to the United States
because of charges dating back to 1977 that he had sex with a 13-year-old girl.
If you follow movies at all, you
have probably heard some version of the events which caused Polanski to flee this
country. But as is often the case when hot-button events are reported in the
popular press, it's probable that what you heard was sensationalized and
incomplete. Marina Zenovich's documentary Roman
Polanski: Wanted and Desired, which premiered at the 2008 Sundance Film
Festival and is now available on DVD,
presents her interpretation of those events, based on archival materials and interviews
with many key players.
Zenovich's conclusion is not
that Polanski is innocent; there's no question that he had sex with an underage
California girl after giving her
Quaaludes and champagne. But Zenovich finds plenty of guilt to spread around to
others involved in the case, beginning with a publicity hound of a judge who
allowed extrajudicial concerns to influence his judgment and committed so many
violations of procedure that a guilty verdict would almost certainly have been
overturned on appeal. Then there was a media eager to exploit the lurid aspects
of the case, and also apparently neglectful parents who may have encouraged
their daughter to engage in the behavior in question in order to further her modeling
career. Think about it: If you had a beautiful 13-year-old daughter with a
successful modeling career, would you let her go on an unsupervised photo shoot
in an isolated location?
While it is certainly no excuse
for statutory rape, it must be said that Roman Polanski experienced a
remarkable amount of suffering. Half Jewish, he survived his childhood in
Nazi-occupied Poland
by hiding in the countryside while his father was confined to the Krakow
ghetto and his mother perished in Auschwitz. He attended
film school in Soviet-occupied Poland
and began acting and directing in the 1950s. He seemed to find happiness in his
marriage to actress Sharon Tate, only to see her brutally murdered by members
of the Charles Manson family. Although Polanski was in London at the time, he
was questioned by the police with regard to the murder, and the tabloid press had
a field day suggesting he had Tate killed as part of a satanic ritual.
Zenovich uses clips from
Polanski's films to propose parallels between their dark view of life and his
own experiences, and suggests that the outsider nature which fueled his
creativity also hampered him in the more mundane aspects of living. One of his
friends commented that Polanski seemed to be missing the playbook for life.
Most of Roman Polanski is concerned with his arrest, trial and decision to
leave the country before sentencing was complete. Zenovich covers a lot of
ground efficiently, in part by having important information and excerpts from
the trial typed on the screen, often in conjunction with archival footage
relating to the same events. It's a good choice which obviates the need for
voice-over or reenactment, and is particularly welcome because in this case the
devil really is in the details.
Polanski's trial was conducted
with an astonishing amount of bad faith. Judge Laurence J. Rittenband lied to
all parties concerned, discussed the case with outsiders, held a press
conference while it was still underway, and was later removed from the case at
the request of both the prosecution and defense. Even district attorney Roger
Gunson agrees that the trial was a sham and Polanski did the right thing in fleeing,
since it was obvious that the judge had no intention of honoring the agreements
made. The case remains officially unresolved today. Polanski lives and works
primarily in France and avoids travel to any country (such as the United
Kingdom) likely to extradite him to the United States.
The DVD
comes with a generous package of extras, including a commentary track by
Zenovich and editor Joe Bini, five deleted scenes and 32 interviews with everyone
from legal experts to Polanski's childhood friends to Mia Farrow and Natassja
Kinski. | Sarah Boslaugh